
It does tend to freak out the Westerners, at least those who haven’t dipped their toe very far into the pool of Chinese cuisine. There it is, a whole fish, sitting on a plate, its eye glaring up at you, and you’re supposed to eat it. Why should you?
Well, how’s this for starters: if there’s one area of cuisine for which Western cooking comes across most clueless compared to Asian, it’s in the treatment of fish. Westerners should know that meat on the bone is best — we’re well versed in the magnificence of a marbled Porterhouse, practically the world experts on just what can be done with a rack of ribs, and every now and then we’ll splurge on the luxury of an expensive rack of lamb. So why do we take a nice fresh fish, and assume that the best thing we could do to it is deftly remove the fillet from the bones, cook it, and serve it up?
To paraphrase Calvin Trillin, you might have a good experience that way, but you haven’t made any effort to take advantage of the percentages. All things being equal, meat on the bone will be far better than meat off the bone, and fish is emphatically not exempt from that rule. One of the simplest and easiest meals you can make, and one of the best, is to take a wonderfully fresh whole fish, spend about 10 minutes dressing it for the steamer, then just let it steam for 10 minutes or so.
I remember watching an early season of the Survivor television show. Maybe it was the second season. Anyway, they’d caught some fish, and it was a festive moment. Here they all were, visibly getting thinner from week to week, making their way with barely enough food, and one of their number had brought home several wonderful fish out of the sea. So what did they do with this bounty of fish? They cut the fillets off of them and cooked them, leaving behind, abandoned, ignored on the discard pile, bones with plenty of meat on them, the head, the cheeks. Even the skin would probably have been tasty, the fish being so fresh. All of this tasty treasure was considered trash, by a group of hungry people. It just goes to show how far the Western idea of what’s edible on a fish has been ingrained in the culture.
The Chinese know better. Sometimes painfully so. I can go to some Bay Area Cantonese restaurants, and have a delicious steamed whole catfish, for far less than $20. But if I go to Hong Kong, many restaurants seem to be charging US$50 and more for a whole steamed fish (Garoupa, usually) no larger than that catfish. I don’t understand why, but it sure is good.
First, of course, you have to get yourself a nice, fresh whole fish. If you do any fishing, of course you’re in great shape, though the recipe that led to the fish pictured above is aimed primarily at neutralish white fish. Fish for perch or pike or bass, and you’re in business. Fish for salmon or bluefish or trout, and some rethinking is in order.
But let’s say you don’t fish. What do you do? I mean, I’m lucky, I live in the Bay Area, and I can get to places that will take a fish out of a tank, give it a couple of whacks on the head, clean it, and send it home with me in a bag. If you don’t have that, though, hope is not lost. Talk to the best fishmonger you can find locally. I would be very surprised if he/she were totally unable to order you a whole fish or two.
There’s another piece of good news here. In Western markets, they charge a bunch of money for fish that is loaded with flavor (fresh sardines are a fortunate exception). Salmon and tuna cost a pile of money. But all you need for a good..no, great steamed fish is a nice neutral whitefish. Sea bass is really great. Tilapia, the cheap junk fish that used to be discarded before the boats reached the shore, is very good, and is in fact my most common choice for steaming, because it is so often available live.
The fish in the picture above isn’t a Tilapia, though. I happened to be at my local Whole Foods (which is about 6x closer to my house than the place that’ll whack a nice Tilapia on the head for me), and I saw a couple of these guys staring out from the fish cooler. They’re called Tai Snapper. No, I have no idea why they’re called that, but their eye was clear (an important indicator of freshness), and they looked cool, and I’d never had them before, so they had to come home with me.
I have a standard default preparation for a whole steamed fish, one which I got from the book that helped me take my journeyman steps in Chinese cooking, Barbara Tropp’s The Modern Art of Chinese Cooking
. It works very well with many neutral white fish, and I love it. But I do feel I’ve only scratched the surface of the possibilities. One favorite Bay Area Cantonese place (I’d tell you what it is, but they changed owners recently, so I don’t know if it’s still good) makes use of yellow chives in their steamed fish, with magnificent results.
But here it is.
Steamed Whole Fish with Black Bean
One whole, very fresh, mild-tasting, white-fleshed fish, gutted and cleaned, scaled, head on
Sauce mixture:
2 teaspoons salted (fermented) Chinese black beans, coarsely chopped
Let’s pause on this ingredient. The brand matters a lot. For some years, I used a brand that came in a plastic bag, with black and white and red on the package. Hearing some talk about vastly superior black beans that come in a yellow cardboard tube, I looked around and found them — and they were about 3x better — richer, earthier, more of everything a black bean should be. It’s worth seeking out these superior black beans. I wish I could show you a picture, but I repackage mine in glass jars, and my Web searches turned up no picture. There’s the brand with the yellow cardboard tube, and there’s also the Pearl River Bridge brand, which should be just as good.
1 tablespoon soy sauce
1 tablespoon rice wine
1 teaspoon sesame oil
1/2 teaspoon sugar
Chop the black beans and mix with the other sauce ingredients
1 1/2 teaspoons fresh ginger, peeled and cut into very fine julienne threads
1 medium or 2 skinny scallions, cut into 2″ pieces
1 to 1 1/2 teaspoons Kosher salt (use 1 teaspoon if not Kosher)
Wash the fish inside and out, pulling any stray dark colored organs out as you wash. Pat dry inside and out.
Cut slits into the fish’s sides, from top to bottom, angled a bit, cutting down to the bone, or almost. Rub the salt into the fish, inside and out, rubbing it into the slits you cut.
Place the fish into a low bowl you can use in your steamer (I use Pyrex pie plates for my small steamer; what’s pictured above is a large one I found for my large steamer). You don’t want a plate — the fish exudes delicious juices during the steaming that are great with rice. Pour the sauce evenly over the fish, then scatter the ginger threads and scallion over it.
Bring water to a full boil in your wok, then add the bowl to the steamer, and the steamer onto the wok. Steam over medium-high heat for 10-15 minutes, depending on the size of the fish. Check after 10 minutes, and every couple of minutes thereafter, until it’s just cooked all the way down to the bone at the thickest flesh.
A fish like this, served with a pile of white rice to soak up the wonderful savory juices, is all you need for an elegant and satisfying meal. And it makes for a very spectacular presentation if you’re serving guests — as long as they can deal with that eye, staring up at them.